BuySI

New Springville / Willowbrook / Bulls Head

Mid-Island
Buyer'sSeller's0 (Buyer's)50 (Balanced)100 (Seller's)68.2

Seller's Market

Heating

Composite score combining supply, pricing dynamics, and speed

New Springville / Willowbrook / Bulls Head is a seller's market. Homes sell in 47 days on average, 1% under asking.

Market Metrics

Pricing

Median Sale Price

$594K

-0.0%YoY

Avg $/Sq Ft

$467

Sale-to-List Ratio

98.7%

% Over Asking

0.2%

% With Price Cuts

N/A

Speed

Median Days on Market

47 days

Sold in <14 Days

0.1%

Sold in <30 Days

N/A

Supply

Active Inventory

108

New Listings

N/A

Months of Supply

1.2

Absorption Rate

83.3%

Volume

Homes Sold

90

Adjust Assumptions

$

New Springville / Willowbrook / Bulls Head median: $594,288

0%Loan: $475K50%
2%10%

Required in FEMA flood zones. Not all areas of SI need this.

Monthly Cost Breakdown

Mortgage (P&I)
$3,005/mo($36,060/yr)
Property Tax
$495/mo($5,943/yr)
Homeowner's Insurance
$186/mo($2,230/yr)
Flood Insurance
$117/mo($1,400/yr)

Zone MODERATE — $800-$2,000/yr

Commute Costs
$127/mo($1,524/yr)

Express Bus

TOTAL MONTHLY COST
$3,930/mo

$47,157/yr

Mortgage (P&I)
Property Tax
Homeowner's Insurance
Flood Insurance
Commute Costs

Estimates for planning purposes. Actual costs may vary. Property tax uses a ~1% approximation; NYC assessments differ. Flood insurance ranges reflect typical NFIP premiums.

Price Trends

Median Sale Price

Avg Price Per Sq Ft

Days on Market

Median Days on Market

Sale-to-List Ratio

Sale-to-List Ratio

Supply & Demand

Supply & Demand

Property Types & Price Distribution

Property Types

Single Family$719K median
Condo$447K median
Two/Three Family$900K median
Three Family$917K median
WAREHOUSES$15.60M median
Vacant Land$293K median
STORE BUILDINGS$2.92M median
OFFICE BUILDINGS$1.07M median
COMMERCIAL VACANT LAND$4.47M median
COMMERCIAL GARAGES$1.23M median
HOSPITAL AND HEALTH FACILITIES$6.00M median
FACTORIES$1.0K median
CONDO PARKING$525K median

Price Distribution

Flood Risk Assessment

Low Risk5% of this area is in a FEMA flood zone

Primary FEMA Zone

Zone X (minimal flood hazard)

Est. Annual Flood Insurance

$300 $500 / year

Area in flood zone5%

Central inland location with minimal flood exposure. Some low areas near Fresh Kills have minor drainage concerns.

Look up your address on FEMA Flood Map Service

Recent Sales

AddressSale PriceSq Ft$/Sq FtLand Sq FtYear BuiltSale DateTypeUnits
$380,0001979Mar 12, 2026Condo1
$1,320,0002,488$5317,2221975Mar 12, 2026Two/Three Family2
$34,0001986Mar 10, 2026Condo1
$816,0001,925$4242,0382014Mar 4, 2026Single Family1
$799,3261,984$4032,5002025Mar 3, 2026Two/Three Family2
$725,0001,548$4681,3301985Feb 27, 2026Single Family1
$475,000993$4781,2711992Feb 27, 2026Single Family1
$794,2351,984$4002,5002025Feb 27, 2026Two/Three Family2
$995,0002,208$4513,2001975Feb 27, 2026Two/Three Family2
$325,0001973Feb 27, 2026Condo1
$740,0002,016$3673,4541980Feb 26, 2026Two/Three Family2
$1,550,0003,664$4235,0001980Feb 26, 2026Single Family1
$880,0002,100$4192,1002000Feb 24, 2026Two/Three Family2
$814,4981,984$4112,5002025Feb 24, 2026Two/Three Family2
$658,8881,330$4951,7602008Feb 24, 2026Single Family1
$550,0001987Feb 20, 2026Condo1
$622,0001988Feb 20, 2026Condo1
$810,0001,664$4876,0001930Feb 20, 2026Single Family1
$939,0002,500$3762,4602001Feb 20, 2026Two/Three Family2
$725,0001,430$5072,2301997Feb 18, 2026Single Family1
$589,0001,700$3462,4671970Feb 13, 2026Single Family1
$505,0002,568$1973,4201975Feb 13, 2026Two/Three Family2
$675,0002,568$2632,5002010Feb 12, 2026WAREHOUSES2
$675,0002,568$2632,5002010Feb 12, 2026WAREHOUSES2
$800,0001,498$5342,5002015Feb 11, 2026Single Family1

Showing 25 of 100 sales

Neighborhood Profile

Population

38,200

Median Income

$85,000

Owner-Occupied

65.0%

Median Age

39.0

Owner vs Renter

Staten Island FerryN/A

Ferry service available from St. George only

SIM Express Bus60 min
Driving42 min

Via Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge

Estimated one-way travel times to Lower Manhattan during weekday rush hour.